Cindy and I are back with another installment in our letters series. They kick this one off on their blog, as we dive into the odds and ends of the Zelda series -- and all of our memories wrapped up in it. Be sure to read the first part on their blog - and while you're there, dive into their year-end pieces.
Hoy, small fry!
That's precious. I love that we both did that in two very different ways - what a sweet story. In a way, we're both Links from different timelines. Or maybe different parts on the same timeline. The mind boggles...
These are stellar choices. I really like what you say about the atmosphere in the Majora's dungeons, because I think that strikes at the heart of what makes that entry so effective. Each set piece feels bespoke, and carries a certain "vibe" with it. That's pretty important to the Zelda experience. And yet you're right - every single biome is interconnected... It refers back to another area, and in the end, affects that central hub of the spoke. It's weird that Majora's does have a hub and spoke design, now that I think about it - a sinister Disneyland.
I think the thing about trying to riff on Zelda is that, from the outset, there often only feels so far a developer can go. Right...? If you set out to recapture the past and riff on it, there's a level of innovation that can sometimes be missed out on. Zelda, as an enterprise, has always been about Nintendo pushing boundaries and innovating in ways that players have not seen prior. To the point where mechanical elements from every entry eventually trickle out into the marketplace. Which - a separate discussion, yes - is connected that Nintendo in-house perspective of games as products vs. art. Novelty is their business. They break the mold, and a lot of developers then try to assemble the pieces into new shapes. So a game whose elevator pitch is, "hey, it's like old Zelda, but different!" can sometimes feel out of step with my interests in the moment. This isn't always true, but I do think there's a reason these smaller, referential titles take a lot of purchase with folks whose main hobby is speedrunning old games, if GDQ and the runners I follow are anything to go by. If your interest in gaming is defined and shaped primarily by games that came out 30-40 years ago, and that hasn't changed, new twists on that will be super appealing to you. And to each their own, of course! Some of those games, like Mina, are really cool. But most aren't my bag.
In terms of your question, I think Zelda shaped my love of narrative not just in gaming. I cut my teeth on the earlier Tomb Raider games, and my relationship with those as a child was very much not with the narratives. Ocarina of Time, specifically, is a game that made me fall in love with characters like nothing had prior. The ensemble cast of that game is so interesting, so dynamic and diverse, that it makes the world feel bigger and richer than perhaps it really is. I was enamored with Saria, mystified by the Gerudo - and had a massive crush on Princess Ruto. That love for those characters, and the childhood yearning I projected onto them, made the stakes of the story feel so much more real. I had genuine emotional investment beyond "beating the game" - and even "beating the game" came with a whole spate of things that made me really upset as a child, like Saria essentially dying.
Which only continued in Twilight Princess - arguably the most narrative and plot-focused title in the series? It's certainly the most dense with cutscenes and rife with exposition, with one of the largest casts. But again - this is where the investment came in. Link's story as a farm boy dragged into a conflict way over his head, plunged into the depths of Hylia and scorched in the desert to protect a world he barely understood while his body underwent strange transformations... In middle school, that narrative resonated with me. I'd just moved from the country to the city, and was desperately trying to make sense of life, so that was one of the major games I grabbed onto. Going from 'Ocarina' to 'Twilight' felt analogous to my experience - tween who didn't feel at home in my body and was re-discovering a city I hadn't lived in for half a decade. Going from N64 Hyrule to Wii Hyrule felt like going from the Jackson County line to Candler Park, in its own way.
That game was probably the very beginning of how I write about and interpret characters in gaming now, thanks to both Ilia and Midna. Ilia, specifically, is fascinating to me. She's this platonic ideal of a blonde, virginal country girl, and the game is preoccupied with protecting her from the outside world. Link's deepest fear, in one cutscene, is the idea that Ilia - this purity, embodied - might become corrupted and drive her into killing him. So there's a lot going on there, right? A lot to play with. And when you relate that idea back into the main story, it's fascinating to pick apart the subtext of Twilight Princess and try to relay it back in a more universal way. So both these games became these golden standards for that, for me - games with rich, complicated characters I could read into, relate to, and come away with a new understanding of the world from. And at risk of sounding like Geoff Keighley, gaming lets the player interface with those experiences in a personalized way that's a transgressive recontextualization of how we've typically understood art. So I craved experiences like that. I craved the ability to control, interact with, befriend, conquer characters that could approach making me feel that way.
This is all a roundabout way of saying Zelda is why I care so much about characters and writing. Because every game - even the most minor entries - have taught me the value of an interesting ensemble. A lot of games spend so much time either building up The Coolest Person Ever as the protagonist or give the player carte blanche to design their own. While this approach is fine, Link's position as an observer allows the player to learn about him and his place organically in every game. As the player's avatar he's meant to experience each character, as Nintendo is trusting the player to draw their own conclusions, form their own opinions, etc. He's not an uninteresting protagonist - rather, his personality, backgrounds, yearnings are filled in by both context and the player's imagination. All the while, they have to ponder the plight of each character - who are they outside of their relationship to Link and their executive power within the context of the plot? That interests me. It interests me because Zelda feels like all the characters have life in them. From the Cuckoo Lady to Raavi to Kafei and Anju to Agitha to Beedle and hell - even fucking Tingle and the little Bomber Boys. They have things going on, mysteries about them we'll never solve. I like that. And I love how the series leaned more into that approach, with the context-based characterization of Breath and Tears.
It's broad, but I think it's fair to say that I compare almost every single game I play to Zelda on this level. Does it make me care about the protagonist? The world? The ensemble? And if not, is it at least fun enough to play to keep going? If it can't do all these things, I'm out. But character and ensemble matter so much to me. It's why I naturally gravitated to Metal Gear and Resident Evil and Final Fantasy and Shin Megami Tensei. Hell - and this will get me crucified - it's why I like most of Rockstar's games. These are games that are not just technically fun to play - they're titles driven by, marketed with, and defined at large by their narratives. And it's also why I'm so willing to bail on a game 10-20 hours in that's 70-80 hours. I love JRPGs and have an ideological opposition to Claire Obscure. But what the real thing and the rich French dad knock-off have in common is that if I don't care about your cast within the first dozen or so hours.... You've lost me! I'm not playing something because the world is cool, it's got dense lore, or it feels good - I need to care about who I am, who's around me, or both. Moment to moment. In any game - competitive shooter, rhythm game, visual novel, adventure game - I need that baseline level of humanity to connect. Otherwise, I won't care. It's why I love Bayonetta but cannot be bothered with any Devil May Cry that isn't the Ninja Theory one - I cannot stand Dante. And I don't doubt those games are good; I've played a good deal of 1,2,3, and 5, actually. But because I think the characters are insufferable, over-the-top figureheads with no depth or pathos, I just don't care.
I do want to say, though - you are right about Zelda fans. They often are wrong. Nintendo fans, in general, have a remarkably poor understanding of the company and series they claim to love. I think there's a contingent of people who have an amber-encased perspective of what Zelda "should" be and it's based purely on what they grew up playing. Which makes sense - clearly, we're in a similar camp. But where I think we differ from this crowd and why I value our discussions is that we understand, on some level, that things must change. If Zelda is going to remain special, it needs to mystify, confuse, and enrapture a generation raised in a very different context than either of us were. And so each evolution, each tweak is a part of that - the idea that anyone, of any age, can go on a grand adventure, solve puzzles, and form meaningful bonds with memorable characters. Motion controls or touch screens, top down or over the shoulder, 2D or 3D, that's what Zelda is to me. However Nintendo accomplishes it, I'm along for the ride.
But I am curious... What are some of your favorite changes in the series over the last 15 years? Let's say 20, even - everything after Twilight. That feels like a good span of time, because I'd wager that's where the biggest shifts took place. How has this series evolved, since you've started, in ways that excited you? Confused you? Frustrated you? And for that matter, how do you think the design philosophy behind Zelda - as an enterprise - feels fundamentally different from, say, the Mario series? Has it changed much, or do you largely think it's the same - just with a new set of tools each time?
Queen Gohma's baby mama,
Maddy

Welcome to the Stock Pot Inn, Maddy!
Honestly, with the whiplash the series has done in the past 15 years, you’d think I would have more frustrations, that just something wouldn’t have worked. But the only one that I didn’t actually get through was Echoes of Wisdom, and I doubt its main conceit is a series shift so much as a single entry. But both it and Tears of the Kingdom have the issue of just being very talkative. And not in ways where it’s interesting. Like, in Breath of the Wild, the stable managers will just sort of wish you a good day when you wake up from sleeping there. In Tears, they tell you a multiple text box tutorial. Every time. And that speaks a bit more to the more worrying trend of Nintendo becoming very guided.
For games like Skyward Sword, the frequent dialogue fits the gameplay. It’s a linear adventure. And even then it gives you some tools, such as dowsing, and trusts you to figure out where to go. Breath of the Wild played into its open fields by having the talking and guidance reserved for the four nations and their Divine Beasts. It trusted me to see a strange mountain shape on the horizon and go for it. But a lot of recent Nintendo titles seem to be going open while also making sure you don’t get lost, in a way that clashes. Donkey Kong Bananza (another game, like Tears and Echoes that you loved and I didn’t) felt the same. And at this point, I’m sure you know about Metroid Prime 4 and its absolute mess of making sure you know where to go at all times.
This is not to say that dialogue is bad. But I think Zelda has always been about capturing the feel of adventure. Miyamoto cited exploring caves behind his house as inspiration for the original. The first moves to 3D added in set pieces to sell the sense of danger and excitement, and entering a dungeon starts with a big camera sweep of the area. Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom set you lose like the original, but this time giving you all the keys at the start. And I feel like everyone comes out of those games telling their own story of what they did. Crafting their own adventure. In that sense, I would actually love a Zelda game where talking and understanding NPCs and the world is more important. Some of Breath’s best bits were sidequests wrapped around a local mystery, or hearing Kass play his accordion and knowing it’s time to solve a riddle. My issue with most of the talking in the games I said about is not that it exists, it’s that they’re not saying anything. There’s rarely an actual voice. But if a Zelda game can make me want to check in with every character, the way Pokemon Legends Z-A had me eager to do all its sidequests, then it could go towards building out the world even more.
But, on that note, there is so much delightful about parsing Zelda lore. Unlike a ton of shows and franchises where every passing mention of history is a canonical event, something that every subsequent entry must adhere to or face the wrath of the online fandom, Zelda has not been afraid to say “yeah I mean fuck it it’s a new time period”. And that makes the little glimmers of canon stand out. The way I lost it when Zelda gets the Master Sword in Tears of the Kingdom and it uses Fi’s leitmotif as she speaks to it. Skyward Sword feels the closest to rooting Zelda details in a set state (it shows how the Master Sword was made, is the first time the Triforce is acquired, and in doing so sets Link, Zelda, and Ganondorf (or Demise…) as the three key players. But there is so much room for interpretation.
Like, and this is just one of my favorite views on Zelda lore, but I think Ilia in Twilight Princess is the reincarnation of the goddess Hylia. A concept that wasn’t in the series at publication, but I don’t care. An assumption with Twilight Princess is that Link is related to the Link from Ocarina of Time, that the mysterious swordsman who teaches him dueling techniques is that same Link and also the new Link’s father. But have we considered that Ilia chooses Link as her champion, that she grants him the power of the Triforce? “Can you at least promise me this?” she says to Link as he’s preparing to leave Ordon Village. “Just come home safely.” Moments later, she is kidnapped, Link goes to save her, and ends up in the Twilight, only being saved from its curse by the Triforce suddenly appearing on his hand. How did it get there? Could the pastoral, childhood friend whose name just so happens to sound like Hylia have blessed him with it unknowingly? Much like the sweet, childhood friend of Skyward Sword, a woman named Zelda who is also the reincarnation of Hylia? Hmm!? Hmmmmmm!?
Anyway, that’s the kind of stuff that I never want the team to tell me about. Please only give unexplained plot threads and recurring symbolism/imagery, thank you. Keep inspiring me and asking me to imagine things. Which is absolutely a crux of Zelda. It leaves enough gaps for us to keep thinking. To go through Ikana Kingdom in Majora’s Mask and wonder what even happened here. Finding village ruins in Breath of the Wild, Zonai statues in Tears of the Kingdom. They even give us tiny notes to imagine who we think Link is, what his attitude is to everyone he meets.
Is this a universal feeling? Do you think about the architecture choices and what they mean? Do you think the actual designers do, or do they just put things in sometimes because they look cool? And do you got any crazy theories? (If you think my Ilia one is out there, how about my longstanding note that in Ocarina of Time, three gods (Red, Green, and Blue) descend on the world, bring it to order, and then leave behind a golden power. In Pikmin 3, three otherworldly explorers clad in Red, Green, and Blue descend on the world, bring the Korok/Picori-like Pikmin to order, and then defeat the golden Plasma Wraith before leaving. Mundane to us, but godly to the little creatures who will know and spread the oldest legends.) Do you have your own pieced together timeline?
We will greet the morning together,
Cind

Cind... Cind... Open your eyes... (It's been a few weeks!)
I really like that Pikmin observation! I never noticed that. I also just also assumed the Ilia/Hylia thing was deliberate, too; maybe she is the reincarnation, or perhaps she's named after the goddess and fate is acting in accordance.
My fan theories for Zelda tend to be less lore-based, more character-based. On some level, I tend to accept each world as its own self-contained story for me to unravel unless I'm told otherwise - i.e. Majora's Mask or Tears of the Kingdom. On some level, if I start to draw parallels between recurrent imagery in distinct Nintendo IPs, I'm afraid I'd start, say, reading too much into the Mario portrait in Ocarina or Yoshi doll in Link's Awakening. Although speaking of which... I like to think that the existence of Yoshi merch in Link's Awakening is some kind of hint that Mario takes place in dreams, or in a reality that's disconnected from Link's normal life. Right? If that game is a reflection of Link's subconscious, and we don't see Yoshi anywhere else in the series IIRC... What does that say about Yoshi? Probably nothing, I realize! But it's definitely something I think about. I think there are fine lines between "imagery artists arrive at habitually," "easter eggs meant to nod to previous works," and "deliberate canon ties"; I think the internet has eroded those lines for some beyond repair.
I think for me, the timeline in Zelda is a tertiary concern when it comes to the actual canon order. My understanding of Zelda is that it is a coalescence of recurring themes, tropes, characters as opposed to a strict series of ordered events. Because even within the mainline timeline, if we're going off that classic Hyrule Historia understanding, there are inconsistencies, plot holes, etc. if we're to hold them to the standard of dense lore. But then - this is why I've always liked Zelda, as opposed to other franchises that draw heavily from European fantasy tropes. You don't really need to memorize a tome, or dig into the geopolitical fineries of Hyrule to appreciate the series. It's not A Song of Fire and Ice - it's a collection of fables with deep meaning imbued into broad archetypes and accessible imagery. That said - I do generally like the order Aonuma et al arrived at, and if we're getting into theories, here's mine: I think Breath and Tears are a convergence point of all the other timelines.
I think dialogue is a tricky thing in Zelda. One of gaming's greatest strengths, as a medium, is its ability to tell a complex, layered story with almost Hemingway-like sparseness in its script. I am playing Final Fantasy IV right now, and that game's script is fairly minimal when held next to, say, a screenplay or book. Yet that doesn't take away from the impact of it all - and at its best, that's also true of Zelda. While I do really appreciate the Warriors-esque political theory and military strategy conversations in Age of Imprisonment, I think my preferred style of Zelda dialogue moves away from that tutorializing that you're mentioning. Which is funny - I feel like Skyward Sword was the first game that really stood out and bothered me with its tutorializing! But I think we have different tolerances, depending on how bought in we are to a specific entry. I'm a big fan of Tears' script, more than Breath's; there's a level of scrappy hope versus pure desolation that really resonated as I went back to it last year. Stuff like the band quest for the Fairy Fountains was fairly open-ended and I really dug that; I think more of that, and less, "hey put on light clothes in hot places," would be ideal.
I do miss the unclear, fuzzy hints of pre-2000 Zelda though - vague "maybe go do something over here and something else will happen" or "that thing you're looking for could be in this part of the map, maybe." I think that speaks to what has been lost not just in Zelda, Metroid, et al, but in game design in general. It's one reason I jived with Hell Is Us so heavily last year; I'm still picking at that game, because there is simply so much there to get lost in. Dark Souls is another great example - specifically DeS, DaS, and Bloodborne. Classic Zelda had a similar level of obfuscation; while I think it's inevitable that Nintendo games ultimately trended towards being more friendly to end users, I think a balance can be struck. It goes back to that example with my mom - she and her friends figured out how to play that game, even not being "gamers" or "nerds" by any stretch. People can figured out more than large-budget developers sometimes give them credit for. That said - I think we can agree that Bananza, Tears, Breath are the start of a good direction for that... right? There's a much more ludic way it allows the player to discover the world in their own order, on their own terms, than games of the 1990s and 2000s. Their games feel less like guided, linear trips through big amusement parks and I appreciate that. I think in some ways, we are in the growing pains phase - how to give autonomy and discovery to a player without leaving newcomers in the dust in a more open, less pre-ordained way.
This is where I'm at, anyway, going into my final bout against Ganondorf in Tears of the Kingdom. Over the past few months, I've basically just been picking away at side-quests - I have all the conditions ready to finally finish the fight, as it were. As we emailed, I did what is probably my single favorite moment in a Zelda game - flying to Zelda as a dragon and pulling the sword out of her head. Realizing that she's been trapped, wandering Hyrule for eons until Link figured it out. Something about that moment made the whole series make sense to me. It is a story of Zelda's belief in prophecy against odds; a willingness to put her life in the hands of ancient gods, demi-gods, and the like. The silent realization on Link's face as he pulled the sword out... that was the moment that reminded me why I fell in love with these games. At its core, it is the story of a girl and a boy, forced together by fate, separated by misfortune, and reunited by a momentum triumph of goodness. The player, then, is the prophecy - we are the thing Zelda believes exists, that will bring Link to her and conquer evil. We are her tool, her belief, her power. To me, the best Zelda games are this realized, with new meaning added by each successive entry and the creatives who work on it - all in conversation with each other on a non-linear timescale.
And on that note - I appreciate the chance to have this conversation with you. Zelda is a touchy subject for fans, but I think that's because it is sacred text - it's the root point of so much of this medium. Whole mechanics and entire genres were birthed by this series, and many of us were raised on it. Like all institutionally recognized texts, there's going to be disagreement and hostility towards open interpretation as long as the text remains relevant. But I believe that's a testament to its strengths, really. That so many people can be united across 40 (!) years of storytelling mechanics, come away with totally different reads, and all ultimately love the same thing. Two generations, now, have grown up with Zelda - yet both of those generations have a disparate understanding and experience of the series. Looking forward, I think the challenge Nintendo faces now is not just satisfying the NES-N64 generation of kids and the GameCube-Switch generation of kids - it's raising a new generation to have these same talks, twenty years from now.
If there's anything that makes me want to peek ahead into the future, it's that. But for now - let's go home, Cin, and regain our lost time. Home... where we are supposed to be... the way we are supposed to be.
Until next time,
Madeline

That wraps it up! Be sure to read my AV Club review of Peow's English release of Stop! Hibari-Kun.
Also -- happy Penitents release year! The book drops in August.
No comments:
Post a Comment