Pages

Friday, September 25, 2026

when anime girls rip ass, that's a-moe

 

Strawberry Marshmallow remains a peak example of moe by letting kids be as weird - and gross - as they are in real life.

It finally happened. I sat down and finished the last handful of Strawberry Marshmallow episodes.

Full disclosure: I've watched the first 8 or 9 episodes a few times over. That started sometime early last decade, near the tail-end of high school. This was the era that I was most into Mitsudomoe and Kodomo no Jikan, so it fit like a glove. But unlike those series, Strawberry Marshmallow doesn't lean into the bawdy or explicit for its comedy. The approach is much more casual-friendly, with an atmosphere that evokes later slice-of-life series like K-On as opposed to the deliberate absurdity of, say, Azumanga Daioh.

But Strawberry Marshmallow, Kodomo no Jikan, and Mitsudomoe have something in common that set these shows apart from other "cute girls doing cute things" series. In these series, the girls are young - we're talking primary school, young. Their designs are informed by classical lo tropes, from the rounded cheeks to their pronounced stomachs attached to oddly defined hips. A disproportionate amount of time is spent, in these works, on children's clothing; each hemline of every denim skirt, frilly dress, or pastel tee is deliberate. There's a love for kids clothes in these work, which results in fresher fits than most kids ever actually have.

"Juvenile moe," I think, best sums up shows like the ones mentioned. These are series that hone in, very specifically, on idealized facets of childhood as seen through the prism of anime. Everything is very heightened in these shows - the children are broad, recognizable tropes meant to be easily identifiable by both glance value and general behavior. These series put those kids in alarming, explicit situations to varying degrees because - like South Park - they're cartoon children played by adults.

Is this weird? I think it's only weird if you're American. America has specific hang-ups with children that are much different than the hang-ups in other cultures. No other show exemplifies this better, I think, than Strawberry Marshmallow. Where Jikan or Mitsudomoe could - at least - be poo-poo'd by certain types for "sexualization" in their humor and plots, the same can't be said for this 12-episode anime or the manga it's based on. There's very little interest in sex here.

Instead, Strawberry Marshmallow lives up to its title by being a sweet, light confection with surprisingly few calories. The premise is simple - Nobue, a chainsmoking college burnout, lives at home and bums between jobs that she's half-invested in. Her real joy is hanging out with her little sister, Chika, along with a cadre of other neighborhood girls. This includes Miu, Chika's next-door neighbor and (mostly) lovable pest who barges in through the window constantly. There's also shy and bespectacled Matsuri, often seen with her pet ferret, and blonde British transfer student Ana.

The cadence of each episode is laid back, as very low stakes are treated with the utmost weight. Most of episode 2, for example, is built around introducing Ana to the cast. For the majority of this episode, Ana struggles to keep speaking in English as she realizes that - living in Japan since she was a toddler - she's mostly forgotten it. There are multiple gags devoted to her saying very basic sentences in English to try and throw off the other girls, only for her to eventually be found out by a simple slip of the tongue. When Ana goes to help Matsuri open with a door, she speaks in casual, plain Japanese much easier than any of her English. Cover: blown.

There's a sociopolitical weight of living in Japan as a white, non-native transplant imbued in Ana. But Strawberry Marshmallow is not interested in peeling back racial hegemony and interrogating it - that's not the name of the game. Remember: very low stakes. The next episode, for instance, has Ana invite Matsuri over to study. But instead of getting any work done, Chika and Miu tag along to ensure constant distraction for the rest of their day. This is the main struggle of the episode - getting homework done while being pulled away by the pratfalls of friends.

But it's not just childhood under the microscope here. In episode 4, Nobue realizes she's out of money for cigarettes - and has no job to speak of. To afford her habit, she takes a series of odd jobs, most notably one as a waitress at a family restaurant. But at every turn, the girls - despite their best efforts - end up getting in Nobue's way. Miu, particularly, continues to demand indulgent orders and constantly pesters Nobue to her breaking point. The girls wind up getting Nobue fired after she snaps at Miu for being a little brat.

Both early adulthood and late childhood are the main focuses of Strawberry Marshmallow. But more often than not, the former is beholden to the latter. Nobue's perspective on the girls is build around her attempts to ply them with treats, and her consistent amusement at their antics. She's harsh sometimes, but more often than not, she acts more annoyed than she actually is. Alone, she'll begin to think of the girls, and wonder what they're up to. She'll consider buying a cake from a lakeside bakery for them, or ruminate on the age she learned the truth about Santa Claus.

Nobue's interest in Matsuri and Ana, too, would likely make a Western non-anime fan uncomfortable. There are light yuri elements between Miu and Chika, and I contend that Nobue is also both queer-coded and um... "minor-attracted." She dotes on both girls throughout the series, plying them with small gifts and going out of her way to make their days better. Much of this is driven by how cute she finds both children, which her internal monologue has no compunction about spelling out for the audience. This goes back to how Nobue is introduced in the manga - a young woman who is wrapped up in the goings-on of neighborhood kids and little else. She promises to "introduce" the reader to each girl, as the world and its players are established through her perspective early on.

It's interesting to think about Nobue as an almost-proxy for Barasui himself. In an early volume of Strawberry Marshmallow, the artist casually mentions that one of his primary inspirations is looking outside at local children. There are moments where Barasui, too, seems to dote on these real-life children from the safety of his own home. From this, it's fair to say one of the biggest influences on why the kids in Strawberry Marshmallow are so cute is because - in part - Barasui finds real children cute.

Is this alarming? To an American, yes. A work like Strawberry Marshmallow could not be made in this country. If an artist casually mentioned they liked to watch children as they passed by their house, took inspiration from their behavior and specific outfits, then drew those girls in various states of repose... Odds are, they're getting put on a list or primed to be publicly tarred into irrelevance. The United States has a strange relationship with children, in general, as evidenced by the deranged calls from both conservatives and liberals to examine kids' junk to make sure they're the "correct" gender.

What's more predatory, I wonder - looking at children from afar or genital exams?

But Strawberry Marshmallow does have some odds and ends that are... questionable! Most pressing is the 2005 PlayStation 2 game, which Barasui did work on and (despite some inconsistencies) can be treated as an "official" representation of the brand. This game takes place from the perspective of a male protagonist, who is a childhood friend of Nobue's visiting for summer vacation. Throughout the visual novel, the MC gets to know each girl from the main cast, and spends time learning what her "summer vacation dream" is. He does through dating each child, in hopes of earning enough favor-ability points to gain her email address. (It's 80, in case you wanted to know.)

On the one hand, I'm a very big advocate for fiction being fiction. Whatever happens to a cartoon child should not be treated nor litigated the same as a real one, because the entire argument of prosecuting imagery is anti-art. On the other hand, this is an absolutely wild and maybe bad premise for a game. There's an almost eerie resemblance to the real-world ways groomers attracted children, entice them with their favorite things, then gain their private contacts and have covert conversations away from adults. This is far from the only lo dating sim in Japan, and before I give the wrong impression - this is an all-ages game. Still, it's a strange context to view these characters in, and easy to question why that was the choice.

But where I think Strawberry Marshmallow avoids criticism is that the most objectionable aspects, to a Westerner, are tucked away in offhand comments by the manga-ka and an untranslated PS2 game from 21 years ago. Further, the series does feel so tangible, so honest in its assessment of what kids are like at 11-12, that it doesn't come across as overt or crass fetish. Instead, it feels like a bittersweet musing of an aging artist who's wistful for the funny, weird innocence of childhood. Barasui is a parent himself, and so a lot of the humor feels derived from real experience with real children.

This is best exemplified by the penultimate episode, "First Snow." After riding her bike to the convenience store for smokes, Nobue falls off her bike and tumbles into a bucket of water left out next to the vending machine. Frozen through, she rushes home to jump into the bath. But as fate would have it, the hot water is busted. Defeated, she huddles up under the heated kotatsu - but it isn't enough. Nobue wrangles the gang together and takes them to a public bath.

After Miu pitches a fit about having to be naked, she joins the girls. But only a scant few peaceful moments pass before a dramatic music swell. Bubbles form underwater, then float up and broach the surface... right between Miu's legs. At first, nothing. Then - Matsuri turns away and covers her nose. Miu looks to her right, only to see that Ana and Chika have fled to the far end of the bath. Finally, Nobue scrunches up her face and leans to interrogate Miu for farting in a public bath.

Fart jokes in anime are gag fodder, as they often are in Western comedy. But Strawberry Marshmallow somehow tries to make rancid child farts moe. There's a tender honesty to the moment, one that practically anyone who has spent time taking care of or being around kids can relate to. Kids are kinda gross! But that's what makes them so cute. And the same thing can be said of human beings. Sure, most of us don't get hot under the collar when someone we love rips ass. At the same time, it takes a genuine kind of love or patience with somebody to get over their bodily functions and still find them adorable.

Recall Sam Neill's story about meeting Princess Di with his son:

There was a royal premiere in London, and it was, it was sort of a fortuitous occasion — you don’t get to sit beside Princess Diana every day. But my son was sitting on the other side [of me] and it was kind of unfortunate, because once it starts getting exciting, about 45 minutes in, he was so carried away with things — he was about 10 years old at this point — he started to fart unreasonably.

This is just the joke from Strawberry Marshmallow, but as observed reality of a late, great actor spending time with British royalty. The story speaks to the universality and the truth of Strawberry Marshmallow - no matter how much you love your kid, they're going to fart and embarrass you sometime. But it takes a special kind of sociopath to get upset at this, or to pretend it doesn't happen, or to carry on as if kids are unvarnished beings that turn into a grunting ogre at puberty. The bathhouse sequence is radical acceptance - an idealized version of a non-ideal, but very real situation.

When Miu farts, this is the essence of moe. Moe is not about thinking an anime girl is cute or pretty; it is a much deeper, more meaningful feeling than aesthetic attraction. Moe is the warm truth somewhere between your chest and stomach. You feel it when an anime character does something which hits so impossibly close to home, it reaffirms their exalted unreality. When an anime girl busts ass, yet isn't framed as a haggard or disgusting ghoul, boundaries around bodily functions are broken in real time. The fart itself becomes cute.

Through this dissonance between the two-dimensional world and our own, that warmth can be held onto as a sacred flame, one that helps reframe and soften the world around us - one anime girl at a time.

No comments:

Post a Comment

letters from Lon Lon and beyond

Between November 6th and November 14th, Cindy and I played through The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (2026 . ) What follows are north of ...