Pages

Friday, September 18, 2026

how do we play video games?

 

in this letter to my lovely friend Cindy, we talk about how we play games - how long we take, what motivates us to replay them, and whether or not we have too much gaming ADHD to be true speedrun pros. as always, the second part of our chat is available on Bloomed Wings!

Cindy,

When speed runners exist, does discourse about game length mean anything?

This is the thought that raced through my brain this past GDQ. During the wrap up of our Zelda letter, we both saw games that took us hours in the series being demolished at record pace. You were there this year - I’m curious how it felt to see first hand. The crowd energy seems infectious, and I’m hopeful to travel to Atlanta for next year’s event. It’s the first in my hometown, and I’ve been particularly homesick lately. Feels like fate.

But if one thing isn’t fate, it’s how long a game takes to beat. This has always been true for me. We’ve talked about a game being too big or too slow before, or perhaps too overstuffed. But in reality, I have a pretty weird relationship with gaming - and it has a large amount to do with speed runs. Years watching GDQ, and to a lesser extent watching runners outside of that, has conditioned me to always look for ‘techs.’ When I watched the Delta play through at GDQ, for instance, there was little surprising because it resembled how that game looked to me when I was playing fast: a lot of dodging and headshots. That isn’t to say I’m nearly that good, but rather, it’s because I’ve spent so long watching people way better at me do cool stuff and it’s impacted how I play.

The Sonic games are a perfect intersection of this. They’re games I know really well - I’ve played every Sonic game at least once, most way, way more than that. A year doesn’t feel right if I don’t have a Sonic story run of Adventure. At this point, my average play through is a combination of learned technique, familiarity, and whatever tricks I saw the last time I watched it played. I wouldn’t call myself close to a runner, but I also wouldn’t say I play Adventure like the average player anymore either.

Which has been a recurrent trend for me, since high school. I’ve had a bad habit of blazing through games as fast as possible because I used to write Amazon reviews the week a game came out. I did this in high school through college - about seven to eight years. Maintaining this pace, unpaid, taught me to be quick and finish the game before anyone else beat me to the punch. Between 2010 and 2016, I would go through a few games a week on average for the blog or Amazon; I’d beat most of these, and if I didn’t, I’d be upfront about that.

By consequence, my time to beat in certain games used to be way lower than the average found on sites like How Long To Beat. It was because I wasn’t taking the time to “Press X to smell the roses,” if you’ll pardon the parlance. I was so goal oriented that I think it stunted my ability to actually enjoy and savor certain experiences without rushing them. It’s the same annoying habit I have as a chronic speed reader: fast basic comprehension at the expense of a more rewarding experience. This often leads to me re-reading passages until I feel like I’ve truly gotten them; I actually do this with games, too, albeit on a longer time scale. If I feel like I’ve blasted through a game one time, I’ll take a longer time on the next play.

Which brings me to a tee off point: how do you play games, Cindy? Do you blaze through them, or scour every inch? Does it depend on the genre? Further - are you about the efficiency or about the little moments? I know your feeling on fast travel, so I have some inkling. But I’m curious how that feeling applies to other aspects of traversing a game and how it relates to overall play time.

Best,
Madeline!

Hey Maddy,

 So if I had to narrow my style of playing a game down, it would be experimental. I am often trying to figure out what I can actually do in the game. And that leads to some varied experiences. Some of them are really positive. Finding enemies to spring on and get to areas that I’m not guided to in Silksong, learning the best ways to chain together moves in RKGK, getting a sick combo in deckbuilders like Monster Train 2 or Death Howl. Other times, though, I end up finding something that is an “effective” way to play and it can actually sour the experience. Digging through the ground is easy and mindless in Donkey Kong Bananza, but it also makes every biome play the same. And yet the part of my brain that has three different punch buttons kept doing it. Similar with making Zonai machines in Tears Of The Kingdom and flying over the map. Great at the start to experiment with, felt rote by the end.

I feel like I go to those two examples constantly (heck, I literally voiced these thoughts on a phone call with you and other friends last night!) but they really stand out as games that feel so big and give me such a wide toolset that I get too wrapped up in what I can do. There are lots of games where I will try and break it, and the rules will tell me “no”, and so I shrug and move on. Sometimes in a bit of a frustrating way (RKGK has a bunch of areas that will turn out to be a bottomless pit or invisible wall, Hades II sets some very arbitrary requirements for gathering materials), but other times in a way that just makes sense (okay fine Metroid Prime 4, I can’t make that jump no matter how hard I try, guess I’ll go somewhere else).

Where the speedrunning side of me really comes out, though, is on replay. A first time through will have me letting go and wandering a world. Poke around and take my time. But then I’ll replay Pikmin 3 and be insistent on escaping the Garden Of Hope on the first visit (which requires getting Rock Pikmin, getting Brittany, beating the Armored Mawdad, and getting the cell phone back to the ship in single day). Or I’ll use the hat dive jump combos in Mario Odyssey that I figured out playing in the post-game to just skip canyons in Tostarena. Understand exactly where I need to go and in what order to do all the sidequests in Majora’s Mask. The unfortunate side is that it sometimes can ruin how a game feels if I’m not doing as well as I know I can. I hit the point where I needed to stop playing Pikmin 3 because if I did a run and failed to clear Garden Of Hope as quickly as possible then I’d just get frustrated to a maybe unhealthy point.

A lot of my favorite games then play into that. The replay factor. Some make it clear for speedrunning (having an achievement for beating the game in under [insert time] hours is a pretty good indicator), but a lot just reward knowledge. Unsighted is one of my favorite games of all time, and a huge part of that is how it becomes absolutely different but not ruined on replay. Like, I don’t think a replay of Outer Wilds will ever feel as good as the first time since just about every key in it is rooted in knowledge. And while I’ll never have the sense of discovery that I did the first time I played Unsighted, half of its secrets are near useless on that first play. The replay feels like a whole new game. Celeste also has some big skips that you can learn by understanding the layout (Golden Ridge and Mirror Temple have some of my favorite ones in general), and also you can just be faster by learning advance tech (wave dash baby!!)

You mentioned replaying Sonic Adventure a bunch, does it have those sorts of factors? Sonic has always been good about stumbling through a level on your first play and actually feeling like the blue blur should on your second. Do you find yourself going to replay games based more on mechanics/depth or by a nostalgia/story factor? And if you’re looking to speedrun these games, is it the knowledge, knowing what turns to hit and where secrets hide, or is it the pure instinct and mechanical mastery that comes from playing the whole thing through once?

— Gotta go fast,

Cindy

That's a great question, Cindy. (And shout-outs to the Odyssey hat dive - that takes me back...)

Nostalgia, I think, definitely plays a part of it. But it is that itch you describe - the knowledge of knowing which turns to hit, when to hit them, what exact way to press the button. There's a fineness to 3D Sonic mechanics that I appreciate - they're twitchy, and often unforgiving. Pressing down an analog stick, in most games, will make Mario run at a pleasant, normal cadence. In an average Sonic title, pressing the stick down for just one second more than you're supposed to can spell death - he'll careen off the stage and clip through the water. In games like Sonic Heroes or Shadow The Hedgehog, this was taken as a bug, not a feature; critics came down on these titles pretty hard for how they felt. Yet I think 20-odd years, now, of 3D Sonic fans have demonstrated that there was always an appeal for that style of play. As you put it, there's a degree of crashing into walls and bumping into stuff on that first playthrough for an average non-fan that - upon replay - gets smoothed out. Adventure, Generations, Forces, and Shadow are one-sitting clears for me now; Heroes is hit or miss. While the games got simpler as the series progressed, it's that twitchiness that has always drawn me to it - mastery over the fine points of control. 

But that's not exclusively it, I feel - and this is where I think you and I have a big overlap. Kirby is probably my favorite Nintendo platformer series, because it's a hybrid experience. It offers that forgiving, lackadaisical 'mushy' gameplay that can be enjoyed by someone of any experience level. But as we discussed on a recent call, there's an unforgiving streak to the games if a player tries to go for 100% completion.  The "hard gameplay" and the "easy gameplay" are the literal same gameplay, just applied differently. This, to me, is where the genius of this series lies - and why it's a prime contender for games I want to learn to run. That first playthrough can be, as you put it, "experimental." "What's this power do?" "How does this block break?" "When does this boss attack?" And the player can poke, prod around Pop Star, Dream Land, or wherever else that game happens to take them without fear of retribution. But then - think about trying to push for 100% in, say, Kirby Super Star Ultra; specifically, the True Arena in that game. It's brutal! And it's tucked away in a game often criticized for being "too easy."

And I like that. It's the same appeal that Luigi's Mansion has to me - a game that's easy enough to clear, but devious to clear well and get everything. This is the ubiquity of Nintendo games, which we've touched on before, but I think they understand replayability better than a lot of other big money rustlers in the space. In the case of both Kirby games and Luigi's Mansion, enough tools are provided to the player for them to engage in their sense of curiosity and exploration without too much punishment. A game like Dark Souls will hide poison rats behind a barrel or tuck a boss away in a random room - this experience is meant to taunt, tease, and titillate the player into continuing. "The audacity! The cheek! It's like they don't want me to finish!" Meanwhile, there's no doubt that Nintendo wants players to finish their games - especially post-GameCube Nintendo. But in order to truly master them, there's a trickiness that - when mastered - leads to an almost different understanding of the game.

To use Luigi's Mansion as a further example, an average player's experience is going to be exploring, getting lost, and maybe not getting all the Boos. A player's knowledge of where everything is in that game is going to cut the playtime in half - itself, already an impressive feat. But then, a fast player isn't necessarily going to get every single piece of treasure, which means they won't get the best mansion. Yet to get the best mansion, the player must also get all 50 Boos on top of the required portrait ghosts. And still, there's one more challenge - getting the different tiers of frame for the ghosts, which range from Bronze to Platinum in the 3DS remake. Do you see where I'm coming from here? It's modular. The game, as a work of art, is so self-sufficient, it doesn't need the stock-standard difficulty modes right out of the gate. To be good at it is - most likely - not the same way another player is going to be good at it. It's a short game, but there are multiple avenues to improve upon depending on your focus. 

Games with "beat in X amount of hours" achievements are big for me, too. I really enjoy running the Resident Evil games for this reason. In high school, I got down to a sub-two hour run of RE5 because of how many times I played it both solo and co-op, trying to get the clear time achievement. Learning enemy animations, figuring out sections to skip, getting into the nitty-gritty with weapon speccing. That obsession led to the Resident Evil series becoming perennial running fodder for me - I could not realistically tell you how many rushed playthroughs of RE4 and RE5 I've done at this point. I also tend to clear all the post-6 games in one or two sittings - RE2 remake, I played twice in the 24 hour launch window. Those games, too, offer that same modularity - sure, you can waste all your ammo, get killed a lot, and not discover any hidden items to bumble your way to an ending. But the real joy comes in figuring out how to get those higher ranks, or finding all the emblems to shoot. Then - knowing that like the back of your hand, and having it become a familiar comfort. (Can you... tell I'm excited for Resident Evil 9?)

I also want to loop back around to something you said - 'souring.' I did not feel that way about Bananza or Tears, sure, but... you hit the nail on the head for how I feel at the end of an average open-world game. Even ones I like! Cars, for instance, become functionally useless by the end of Saints Row IV. And Breath of the Wild would've been killed for me, had the motorcycle been available right out of the gate. I think games that give players a 'super-powered' way to get around the map can ultimately all fall into this pitfall. Think of how many cool vehicles there are in the Just Cause games that a lot of players don't ever see because they were wingsuiting and para-gliding around the map! Sometimes, once you find the "trick" to movement, the rest of a game can start feeling really shallow. It's how I felt, ironically, about Sonic Frontiers - a game that guides players through so much of the stale open world through speed boost and rails, you start to wonder why it's an open world game to begin with. I think, to a degree, a good 'sit down and blast through it' game has to have a more closed space for me - a momentum barreling towards an endpoint. Even a lot of Zelda fits that criteria, if you know where you're going.

Perhaps that's just it - 'if you know where you're going.' I like a game that can be over in an hour if you're great at it, and over in 10 if you're unfamiliar, but either way, it's an enjoyable experience. Does that make sense? That's why length is, perhaps, so relative to me. I've played 70+ hour wastes of my life, and 30 minute experiences that have enriched my appreciation of life. So a game that can sustain my attention the first go-round, then reward my mastery in each subsequent playthrough... That's what I'm looking for. Maybe not just in speedrunning, but in games in general. It goes back to my mom - the first speedrunner I ever knew. Sitting on the floor of our living room, trying to beat her personal record on MediEvil; she got to the point where she could beat it in about an hour. In a way, whenever I try to get good at a game, it's really chasing how good my mom got at that one...

But what about you? What motivates you to play through something again, once you know it's a certain length? Further - what motivates you to play something a fourth, eighth, maybe twelfth time? Is it that personal satisfaction - the knowledge that you can do certain tricks that would've baffled you as a kid? Do you foster hopes of becoming the next ace speedrunner? Or does the process of blazing through a game - and poking/prodding at the mechanics - unlock a deeper, more complex appreciation of the art form?

Stay speedy,

Maddy

you can read the second part of this post over on Bloomed Wings.

No comments:

Post a Comment

letters from Lon Lon and beyond

Between November 6th and November 14th, Cindy and I played through The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (2026 . ) What follows are north of ...